| Severity | Features | PEF | SpOโ on RA | Disposition |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Mild–Moderate | Speaks in sentences, RR < 30, HR < 120, alert | > 50% predicted | > 92% | ED treat & reassess; discharge if responsive |
| Severe | Speaks in phrases or words, accessory muscle use, RR > 30, HR > 120, agitated | < 50% predicted | < 92% | Admit; consider ICU if no response in 1h |
| Life-threatening / near-fatal | Silent chest, drowsy/confused, bradycardia, cyanosis, paradoxical chest/abdomen, exhaustion | < 33% predicted (or unable) | < 90% | ICU. Prepare for intubation. |
| "Quiet chest" is the most dangerous sign, no air movement = no wheeze. Rising PaCOโ on a tiring asthmatic is impending arrest, not a relief. | ||||
| Decision | Acute asthma | AECOPD |
|---|---|---|
| Albuterol frequency | q20 min × 3 in first hour, front-loaded | q1–4 h scheduled, no q20 min loading |
| Continuous nebs (albuterol) | Yes for severe (albuterol 10–15 mg/hr via large-volume nebulizer) | Rarely; intermittent dosing works and chronic patients don't tolerate continuous |
| Ipratropium duration | First 3 nebs only (ceiling effect, Rodrigo 2005) | Continued throughout admission (often DuoNeb q4–6 h) |
| Oโ target | 93–95% | 88–92% (controlled Oโ, avoid hypercapnic respiratory failure) AVOID, 2010 |
| Steroids | Prednisone 40–60 mg × 5 d | Prednisone 40 mg × 5 d REDUCE, 2013 |
| Antibiotics | Usually NO | YES if Anthonisen ≥ 2 of 3 (↑ dyspnea, sputum volume, sputum purulence) |
| NIV | Bridge only, low threshold to intubate | First-line for hypercapnic exacerbation (strong evidence; 65% relative reduction in intubation, 46% reduction in mortality per Cochrane meta-analysis, Osadnik 2017) |
| IV magnesium | 2 g IV over 20 min for severe (per 3Mg, 2013) | Not standard, weak evidence |
| Decompensation tempo | Hours | Days |
| Drug | Common (most patients) | Watch for / cautions |
|---|---|---|
| Albuterol (SABA) | Tachycardia, fine tremor, anxiety | Hypokalemia (ฮฒโ shifts K⁺ into cells, repeat BMP after continuous nebs), lactic acidosis (ฮฒโ-driven type B, do NOT mistake for sepsis), hyperglycemia, QT prolongation at high cumulative doses, paradoxical bronchospasm (rare). |
| Ipratropium | Dry mouth, metallic taste | Mydriasis / acute angle-closure glaucoma if mask leaks into eye (use mouthpiece or seal mask). Urinary retention in elderly men with BPH. Avoid in true peanut/soy allergy (older formulations). |
| Prednisone / Methylprednisolone | Hyperglycemia, insomnia, mood lability, increased appetite | Anticipate insulin needs in diabetics (BG often jumps 100–200 within 24 h). Steroid psychosis at high doses or in elderly. HTN, fluid retention. GI upset (consider PPI if high-risk). No taper needed for ≤ 5 days. |
| Magnesium sulfate IV | Flushing, warmth, mild nausea | Hypotension with rapid infusion (the main reason for 20–60 min run-time). Diminished deep tendon reflexes at level > 4 mEq/L; respiratory depression / arrhythmia at > 8–10. Reduce dose in renal failure (accumulates, monitor reflexes). |
| Epinephrine IM | Palpitations, tachycardia, tremor, anxiety, HTN, headache | Arrhythmia and ischemia risk in elderly / CAD, but life-threatening asthma overrides relative contraindications. IM (not IV) for asthma; IV epi is for arrest only. Avoid mixing with beta-blocker on board if alternatives exist (unopposed alpha can spike BP). |
| IV / SQ Terbutaline | Tachycardia, tremor, palpitations | Tachyarrhythmias (continuous tele required), hypokalemia, lactic acidosis (ฮฒโ-driven), hyperglycemia, myocardial ischemia in CAD. Check ECG and electrolytes q2–4h on infusion. |
| Ketamine | Hypertension, tachycardia (often beneficial here), increased secretions, nystagmus | Laryngospasm (rare but dangerous in asthma, paradoxical airway compromise). Co-administer glycopyrrolate 0.2 mg IV to dry secretions. Emergence reactions on awakening (treat with low-dose midazolam). Theoretical ICP concern in TBI but not a contraindication in modern practice. |
| Heliox | None directly (inert gas) | FiOโ ceiling: ratio is fixed (70:30 or 80:20), so cannot use if patient needs more Oโ than that delivers. Voice changes (Donald Duck effect) is harmless but disconcerting. Bridge only, does not treat the underlying obstruction. |
| Step | Choice | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Pre-oxygenate | NRB + nasal cannula 15 L apneic Oโ | Asthmatics desat fast, FRC is shrunken with air trapping. HFNC if available. |
| Resuscitate before intubate | 500–1000 mL NS bolus, push-dose epi/phenylephrine ready | Positive-pressure ventilation drops preload severely in air-trapped patients. Pre-empt hypotension. |
| Induction | Ketamine 1.5–2 mg/kg IV | Drug of choice. Bronchodilator, preserves BP, dissociative. Avoid propofol (drops BP) and etomidate (no bronchodilation). |
| Paralytic | Rocuronium 1.2 mg/kg IV | Avoid succinylcholine if hyperK risk (severe acidosis can shift K⁺ up). Rocuronium reversible with sugammadex. |
| Tube size | Largest that fits (8.0–9.0 in adults) | Reduces airway resistance and allows bronchoscopy / pulmonary toilet. |
| Setting | Target | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Mode | Volume control (AC/VC) | Predictable Vt, lets you measure plateau and auto-PEEP precisely. |
| Tidal volume | 6–8 mL/kg IBW | Smaller Vt = less hyperinflation. Don't try to "blow off" COโ with bigger breaths. |
| Respiratory rate | 6–10 breaths/min | Long expiratory time. Slow rate is the single most important setting. |
| I:E ratio | 1:4 to 1:5 | Inspiratory time 0.8–1.0 s, leave the rest for exhalation. |
| Inspiratory flow | 80–100 L/min (high) | Deliver Vt fast so most of cycle is exhalation. |
| PEEP | 0–5 cm HโO (low or zero) | Adding extrinsic PEEP can worsen hyperinflation. Some titrate to ~80% of measured auto-PEEP if patient is triggering. |
| Plateau pressure | < 30 cm HโO | Reflects alveolar pressure; high plateau = barotrauma + hypotension risk. Peak pressure can be high (resistance) and that's OK if plateau is fine. |
| pH / PaCOโ | Accept pH ≥ 7.15–7.20, any PaCOโ | Permissive hypercapnia. Don't chase normocarbia, that's how you kill the patient. |
| Sedation | Deep + paralytic if needed | Ventilator dyssynchrony in asthma is fatal. Continue inhaled bronchodilators in-line with circuit. |
| Step | Track 1 (Preferred) | Track 2 (Alternative) | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| Step 1 (Mild intermittent) | As-needed low-dose ICS-formoterol (e.g., budesonide-formoterol PRN) | Low-dose ICS whenever SABA used | No more SABA-only. SYGMA, 2018: PRN budesonide-formoterol was superior to SABA alone for severe exacerbation prevention. |
| Step 2 (Mild persistent) | As-needed low-dose ICS-formoterol | Daily low-dose ICS + SABA PRN | ICS reduces exacerbations, hospitalizations, and death from asthma. This is the foundation. START, 2003 |
| Step 3 (Moderate) | Low-dose ICS-formoterol maintenance + reliever (MART / SMART therapy) | Low-dose ICS-LABA + SABA PRN | MART (GINA term) = SMART therapy (NHLBI / US term) = Single (or Same) Maintenance And Reliever Therapy. One inhaler used for both daily controller and as-needed rescue. Reduces severe exacerbations vs traditional ICS-LABA + SABA PRN. FACET, 1997 |
| Step 4 (Moderate-severe) | Medium-dose ICS-formoterol maintenance + reliever | Medium/high-dose ICS-LABA + SABA PRN | Consider adding LAMA (tiotropium) if uncontrolled. Single-inhaler triple therapy (ICS/LABA/LAMA) reduces exacerbations vs ICS/LABA. CAPTAIN, 2020 · TRIMARAN/TRIGGER, 2019 · SHINE, 2014 |
| Step 5 (Severe) | Refer to specialist. High-dose ICS-LABA + LAMA. Phenotype: eosinophilic โ add biologic (anti-IgE, anti-IL5, anti-IL4R). Low-dose OCS as last resort. | Biologics: omalizumab (Xolair) anti-IgE; mepolizumab (Nucala) / benralizumab (Fasenra) anti-IL-5; dupilumab (Dupixent) anti-IL-4Rα; tezepelumab (Tezspire) anti-TSLP. See Medications tab for trial citations and indication criteria. | |
| Feature | Asthma | COPD |
|---|---|---|
| Exacerbation tempo | Fast. Can go from "talking in sentences" to silent chest / peri-arrest in hours. Less reserve, acute bronchospasm on top of baseline normal lungs. | Slow. Usually builds over days. Patients tolerate higher PaCOโ at baseline (chronic COโ retention). |
| Time to intubation | Sooner. Asthmatics tire and crash quickly once accessory muscles fail. NIV trial is shorter (1–2 h max), low threshold to intubate if not improving. | Later. NIV (BiPAP) avoids intubation in > 80% of COPD exacerbations strong NIV evidence base. Can support on NIV for many hours to days. |
| NIV response | Less validated. Used as a bridge, not a definitive therapy. If pH or PaCOโ trending the wrong way at 1–2 h, intubate. | First-line for acute hypercapnic exacerbation (pH < 7.35, PaCOโ > 45). Reduces intubation, mortality, and length of stay. |
| Age of onset | Usually childhood / young adult | Usually > 40, smoker |
| Reversibility | Reversible (FEVโ improves ≥ 12% + 200 mL post-bronchodilator) | Irreversible (FEVโ/FVC stays < 0.70) |
| Inflammation | Eosinophilic (Th2, IgE-mediated) | Neutrophilic (CD8+, macrophages) |
| ICS role | Cornerstone of therapy | Add-on only if eos ≥ 300 |
| Drug | Dose | Route | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| Fluticasone/salmeterol | 100–500/50 BID | DPI | ICS/LABA, Steps 3–4 |
| Budesonide/formoterol | 80–160/4.5 | DPI | SMART/MART (controller + reliever) |
| Tiotropium Respimat | 2.5 mcg 2 puffs daily | Inhaler | LAMA add-on, Steps 4–5 |
| Prednisone | 40–60 mg × 5 d | PO | Exacerbation, no taper needed |
| Biologic | Target | Use when | Dose | Key trials |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Omalizumab (Xolair) | Anti-IgE | Moderate-severe allergic asthma, age ≥ 6, IgE 30–700 IU/mL + perennial aeroallergen sensitivity (skin test or specific IgE +) | 75–375 mg SQ q2–4wk (weight + IgE based) | INNOVATE 2005 EXTRA 2011 |
| Mepolizumab (Nucala) | Anti-IL-5 | Severe eosinophilic asthma, age ≥ 6, eos ≥ 150 at start OR ≥ 300 in past 12 mo, ≥ 2 exacerbations/yr on high-dose ICS-LABA | 100 mg SQ q4wk (adult); 40 mg (peds 6–11) | DREAM 2012 MENSA 2014 SIRIUS 2014 |
| Benralizumab (Fasenra) | Anti-IL-5Rα (ADCC, depletes eos) | Severe eosinophilic asthma, age ≥ 12, eos ≥ 300 (some sources ≥ 150), uncontrolled on high-dose ICS-LABA | 30 mg SQ q4wk × 3 doses, then q8wk | SIROCCO 2016 CALIMA 2016 ZONDA 2017 |
| Dupilumab (Dupixent) | Anti-IL-4Rα (blocks IL-4 + IL-13) | Moderate-severe asthma, age ≥ 6, eos ≥ 150 OR FeNO ≥ 25, especially with atopic dermatitis / CRSwNP / EoE. Also OCS-dependent asthma regardless of phenotype | 200–300 mg SQ q2wk (after 400–600 mg load) | QUEST 2018 VENTURE 2018 |
| Tezepelumab (Tezspire) | Anti-TSLP (upstream alarmin) | Severe asthma, age ≥ 12, uncontrolled on high-dose ICS-LABA, regardless of eos or IgE. The choice when phenotype is unclear or biomarkers are low | 210 mg SQ q4wk | NAVIGATOR 2021 SOURCE 2022 |
Patient: 22F, moderate persistent asthma on medium-dose ICS/LABA (non-adherent), presents with acute dyspnea, wheezing, and inability to speak in full sentences after URI exposure.
Key findings: HR 124, RR 32, SpO2 88% on RA. Peak flow 120 L/min (predicted 450). Accessory muscle use, paradoxical breathing. ABG: pH 7.38, pCO2 40 (ominous, should be low in acute asthma).
Management:
Teaching point: A normal or rising pCO2 in acute asthma is an ominous sign. Patients with severe bronchospasm should be hyperventilating (low pCO2). A "normal" pCO2 of 40 means the patient is tiring and respiratory failure is imminent. Rowe et al., 2000
Patient: 35M, moderate persistent asthma on fluticasone/salmeterol 250/50 BID. Reports nocturnal symptoms 4x/week, rescue inhaler use daily, 2 ED visits in past 6 months. ACT score 12 (poorly controlled).
Key findings: Spirometry: FEV1 68% predicted, 14% improvement post-bronchodilator. FeNO 58 ppb (elevated, suggests eosinophilic inflammation). Blood eos 480/mcL.
Management:
Teaching point: Before adding expensive biologics, fix the basics: 70-80% of patients use inhalers incorrectly, and non-adherence is the most common reason for "refractory" asthma. Always check technique, adherence, and triggers before escalating GINA steps. SYGMA 1 & 2, 2018
Patient: 19M, severe persistent asthma, prior ICU admission x 2, presents in extremis. Unable to speak, minimal air movement ("silent chest"), altered consciousness.
Key findings: HR 140, RR 8 (bradypneic, pre-arrest), SpO2 78%, GCS 10. ABG: pH 7.12, pCO2 85, pO2 52. Peak flow unmeasurable.
Management:
Teaching point: The "silent chest" with bradypnea is pre-respiratory arrest. After intubation, the greatest danger is dynamic hyperinflation (breath stacking → auto-PEEP → decreased venous return → PEA arrest). If a patient crashes post-intubation, disconnect from the ventilator and manually decompress. Permissive hypercapnia saves lives in status asthmaticus.