Add sedation ONLY after adequate analgesia. Target lightest effective sedation -deep sedation kills ICU patients. PADIS, 2018
Have you treated pain first? Before reaching for a sedative, ensure fentanyl (or equivalent) is optimized. If CPOT โฅ 3 โ the patient needs more analgesia, not sedation. Go to Analgesia Guide.
Sedation Agent Comparison
Agent
Dose
Onset
Best For
Avoid When
Key Side Effects
Propofol (Diprivan) (Diprivan) 1ST LINE
5โ50 mcg/kg/min IV
30โ60 sec
Most ventilated ICU patients. Rapid on/off -ideal for daily SAT, neuro checks.
Hypotensive patient needing sedation โ Ketamine (supports BP). Or low-dose propofol with vasopressor support.
Alcohol/benzo withdrawal โ Benzodiazepines (CIWA-guided). Phenobarbital for severe/refractory. Add dex as adjunct.
Severe ARDS + NMB โ Deep sedation (RASS โ3 to โ4). Propofol or midazolam + fentanyl. Ensure adequate analgesia -paralyzed patients cannot communicate pain.
Procedural sedation โ Propofol 0.5โ1 mg/kg bolus ยฑ fentanyl. Etomidate for cardioversion. Ketamine for hemodynamically unstable procedures.
Key Pearls
Light sedation saves lives. RASS โ1 to 0 reduces ICU mortality, ventilator days, and long-term cognitive impairment vs deep sedation. There is almost never a reason for RASS โ4/โ5 without NMB.
Benzos cause delirium. Midazolam and lorazepam are independently associated with โ delirium and โ mortality compared to propofol or dexmedetomidine MENDS, 2007SEDCOM, 2009. Never use as first-line ICU sedation.
Dexmedetomidine is the only sedative without respiratory depression. Can sedate non-intubated patients (post-extubation agitation, NIV patients, procedural sedation).
Daily SAT + SBT. Every day ask: can we turn off sedation? Can we do a breathing trial? The ABCDEF bundle reduces mortality and delirium. Do it every single day.
Special Clinical Scenarios
Alcohol / Benzodiazepine Withdrawal
Benzodiazepines are the treatment -NOT propofol or dexmedetomidine alone.
CIWA-Ar score q4โ8h -score > 8 โ treat
Lorazepam 1โ4 mg IV q1h PRN (symptom-triggered) OR diazepam 5โ20 mg PO/IV PRN
Severe/refractory (CIWA > 20): phenobarbital 130โ260 mg IV q15โ30 min until controlled
Add dexmedetomidine as adjunct for autonomic symptoms (tachycardia, HTN)
Thiamine 100 mg IV before any glucose (prevents Wernicke's)
Delirium Management
Non-pharmacologic first: reorientation, day/night cycle, early mobility, hearing aids/glasses
Dexmedetomidine -reduces delirium duration vs benzos MENDS, 2007
Midazolam 1โ2 mg IV + fentanyl 25โ50 mcg (or local only)
Cardioversion
Propofol 0.5โ1 mg/kg IV or etomidate 0.2 mg/kg IV
Paracentesis / thoracentesis
Topical lidocaine only; add midazolam if anxious
Pimp Questions
What is propofol infusion syndrome and how do you recognize it?
Rare but fatal complication of high-dose (> 4 mg/kg/hr) or prolonged propofol. Caused by impaired mitochondrial fatty acid oxidation. Features: new metabolic acidosis + elevated lactate, rhabdomyolysis, hyperkalemia, lipemic plasma, Brugada-like ECG, cardiac failure. Treatment: stop propofol immediately, switch agent, supportive care.
Why are benzodiazepines associated with worse ICU outcomes?
MENDS, 2007SEDCOM, 2009: more delirium, longer ventilator time, increased ICU stay vs propofol or dexmedetomidine. Accumulate in renal/hepatic failure. Paradoxical agitation in elderly. Reserve for withdrawal and status epilepticus only.
What makes dexmedetomidine unique compared to other sedatives?
Only ICU sedative without respiratory depression. Mechanism: ฮฑโ agonism (locus coeruleus) โ sleep-like state, patients arouse easily. Can sedate non-intubated patients, continue during vent weaning, and doesn't interfere with respiratory drive during SBT.