Opioid use disorder is a chronic medical disease, and the medications that treat it are among the most effective interventions in medicine. Treatment with buprenorphine or methadone substantially reduces all-cause and overdose mortality, with cohort data showing mortality roughly halved or better while patients are retained in treatment. Framing this as a moral problem, or as something to be addressed after the "real" medical issue, costs lives in a way that few other omissions on a medicine service do.
Counseling alone is not equivalent to medication. Referral to a program without medication, or a "detox" admission with no medication at discharge, is not neutral: it is associated with worse outcomes than medication treatment. This is the single most common well-intentioned error in this disease.
| Screen for | Why, and what to do |
|---|---|
| HIV and hepatitis C | Both are substantially more prevalent with injection use, and both are treatable to the point of cure or durable control. HCV is curable with direct-acting antivirals, and ongoing drug use is not a reason to withhold treatment. Offer HIV pre-exposure prophylaxis to those at continued risk. |
| Hepatitis B, plus vaccination | Screen and vaccinate the non-immune. Also vaccinate against hepatitis A and confirm tetanus status. |
| Infective endocarditis | A common and frequently missed cause of admission. Have a low threshold for blood cultures and echocardiography with fever plus injection use. Right-sided disease is classic but left-sided occurs and behaves differently. |
| Skin, soft tissue and bone | Abscess, cellulitis, osteomyelitis and epidural abscess. Back pain with fever in someone who injects deserves imaging, not analgesia alone. |
| Psychiatric comorbidity | Depression, anxiety, PTSD and other substance use disorders are common and affect retention. Concurrent benzodiazepine or alcohol use raises overdose risk but is not a reason to withhold buprenorphine or methadone. |
| Pregnancy | Changes management substantially. Buprenorphine or methadone is the standard of care in pregnancy; withdrawal management alone is not recommended because relapse risk is high and carries fetal risk. Coordinate with obstetrics and pediatrics early. |
| Drug | Mechanism | Practical points |
|---|---|---|
| Buprenorphine usually with naloxone | Partial mu agonist with very high receptor affinity | The ceiling effect on respiratory depression is what makes it comparatively safe -partial agonism means the respiratory effect plateaus, so overdose risk is far lower than with a full agonist. The same high affinity is why it displaces full agonists and precipitates withdrawal if given too early. Prescribable in any office setting with a standard DEA registration. The naloxone component is poorly absorbed sublingually and is there to deter injection, not to treat. |
| Methadone | Full mu agonist | No ceiling effect, so respiratory depression remains possible and dose increases must be cautious. Long and variable half-life means accumulation over the first days, when overdose deaths cluster. Also prolongs the QT interval. For ongoing OUD treatment it must be dispensed through a licensed opioid treatment program, not by outpatient prescription. |
| Naltrexone extended-release injectable | Opioid antagonist | Blocks rather than activates, so there is no withdrawal relief and no diversion value. ⚠ Requires roughly 7 to 10 days opioid-free before the first dose, or it precipitates severe withdrawal -which is exactly why it is hard to start in the people who need treatment most, and why many who intend to start it never do. X:BOT, 2018 quantified this: the intention-to-treat advantage for buprenorphine came largely from patients who never got started on naltrexone at all, whereas among those successfully inducted the two performed comparably. The induction barrier, not the drug's pharmacology, is the problem. Best suited to patients already through withdrawal, such as those leaving controlled settings. Tolerance is lost while blocked, so overdose risk is high if the injection lapses. |
"Ms. T is a 34-year-old woman who injects fentanyl daily, admitted with tricuspid valve endocarditis and Staphylococcus aureus bacteremia, now day two of a planned six-week antibiotic course. Overnight her COWS rose to 14 with objective sweating, mydriasis and gooseflesh, and she has asked twice about leaving. I think the withdrawal is the immediate threat to her antibiotic course, because undertreated withdrawal is a leading modifiable reason patients in her situation leave against advice, and leaving on day two of endocarditis treatment is a far greater risk to her than her drug use is this week. Given daily fentanyl I am not comfortable with a traditional induction despite the COWS of 14, since fentanyl redistributes from fat and she could still precipitate. I have asked addiction medicine to help choose between a low-dose overlap and a high-dose initiation, and I have started symptomatic management meanwhile. She has not been screened for HIV or hepatitis C, so I have sent both and checked hepatitis B immunity for vaccination. For discharge she will need naloxone with training for her partner, counseling on lost tolerance, and a confirmed appointment rather than a phone number, since referral without a booked follow-up usually fails. I would also flag in the chart that her buprenorphine must not be held if she needs a procedure."
| Decision | Approach and why |
|---|---|
| Framing | A chronic treatable disease whose medications substantially reduce mortality. Counseling or referral without medication is not equivalent, and a withdrawal-only admission leaves the patient at higher overdose risk than before, because tolerance falls faster than the drive to use returns. |
| Who can prescribe | The X-waiver is gone (Consolidated Appropriations Act 2023). Any DEA registration with Schedule III authority, no patient cap. |
| Diagnose | DSM-5: 2-3 mild, 4-5 moderate, 6+ severe. Tolerance and withdrawal do not count when opioids are taken as prescribed -dependence is not the same as a use disorder. |
| Choose the drug | Buprenorphine (partial agonist, ceiling on respiratory depression, office-prescribable) or methadone (full agonist, no ceiling, accumulates early, QT, needs an opioid treatment program) -both have the strongest mortality evidence. Naltrexone needs 7-10 opioid-free days, which is why it so often never gets started. Patient preference predicts retention, and retention produces the survival benefit. |
| ⚠ Induction | Classic: wait for COWS ~8-12. But fentanyl is lipophilic and redistributes from fat, so drug persists past 8-24 h despite a convincing score. Use low-dose overlap (small escalating doses while the full agonist continues, no withdrawal required) or high-dose initiation (~1-5% precipitated withdrawal in fentanyl-positive ED patients). Involve addiction medicine. |
| ⚠ Acute pain on MOUD | Never stop the maintenance dose. It gives no meaningful analgesia, so stopping it only adds withdrawal to pain. Continue it and treat pain on top, expecting higher full-agonist requirements; use multimodal and regional techniques. |
| Screen | HIV, HCV, HBV with vaccination; endocarditis, skin, soft tissue and spinal infection; psychiatric comorbidity. Ongoing use is not a reason to withhold HCV cure. In pregnancy, buprenorphine or methadone is standard and withdrawal management alone is not recommended. |
| Discharge | Naloxone with a trained bystander, lost-tolerance counseling, "don't use alone", and a booked appointment rather than a phone number. |